About OgreCave and its staff

Recent Reviews
Goblin Grapple
(Silver Gaming Co.)
(505 Games)
Pathfinder Card Game
(Paizo Publishing)
Cthulhu Invictus Companion
Boss Monster!
(Brotherwise Games)
Murder of Crows
(Atlas Games)

Archive highlights
GAMA Trade Show 2008 report, part 2
GAMA Trade Show 2008 report, part 1
Frag Beta Capsule Review (4/14/01)
Battle Cattle Minis Preview (2/28/01)

Reviews: BESM Fantasy Bestiary
by Cedric Chin

BESM Fantasy Bestiary cover

BESM: Fantasy Bestiary

Written by Jeff Mackintosh, Anthony Ragan, and Niko Geyer
Ary by Nikoy Geyer
Published by Guardians of Order
96 b & w pages

Call Big Eyes, Small Mouth an "anime game" and you'll be told it's more than that. BESM is based on the generic Tri-Stat system, adaptable to any form of roleplaying. Want proof? Just take a look at the very successful Silver Age Sentinels, a superhero roleplaying game also using the Tri-Stat system. And maybe it's time to apply Tri-Stat to traditional fantasy roleplaying.

BESM Fantasy Bestiary (and upcoming BESM books) is a step towards traditional fantasy roleplaying. Before you say, "Sell out!", fantasy does have a place in anime: anything from the over-the-top Slayers, to the more serious Lodoss Wars, to the part D&D, part heavy metal Bastard! anime series. Furthermore, of the modern roleplaying genres, an anime-based one is the most likely place you'll find angels, demons (even non-tentacled ones), and occasional ghost, all quite at home in fantasy.

The book itself is 96 black-and-white pages, in the 6" x 9" digest-sized format used by BESM products. About every fourth page is art, much of it from the 2003 Fantasy Bestiary Calendar, also by GOO. The art reproduction is occasionally on the murky side, but still better than your average rpg interiors. While the art is anime-influenced, few of the creatures have the ubiquitous saucer-shaped eyes (in other words, it's safe to show otaku philistines -- er, your non-anime viewing friends).

The book has a total of 63 creatures, plus 12 sample magical items. Categories are Character Races, Creatures of Myth, Dinosaurs, Faeries, and Undead. (The Character Races lean towards humanoid creatures, and Creatures of Myth are non-humanoid.) The creatures are of the traditional European fantasy roleplaying variety. As implied, traditional creatures often found in anime, such as angels, demons, and ghosts -- including the Ghost of a Wronged Woman -- are included.

Each of the creatures is given a page, and presented as a NPC-like stat block. Each page is divided into an introduction, a template, minor version of the creature, and major version. The template is included so players and GMs can create customized characters. A template for every creature is a wise idea: in most anime I've seen, the best fantastic creatures are singular and unique. Also, in anime, you can pretty much count on any humanoid race or life form to be a major character. Anyone for a dryad (who has to enroll in high school, of course) as a "magical girlfriend"?

The magic item section is only three pages long, but contains concise construction advice and sample items. While the items pretty much just modify skills and attributes, the samples are there to suggest the depth and background they can add to a game. For example, the "Light Armor Level 2" magic item is titled, the "Armour of Leaves", and is described as a weave, by young dryads, of "magical armor of leaves and twigs from materials brought by their animal friends". (Tugs your heart, don't it?)

If there's anything missing from this book, it's the now-standard GM advice that comes in roleplaying game books. I've actually provided more suggestions in this review on how to use the book than the book itself does (the book doesn't even contain adventure seeds or suggestions for use in your anime-based games). Likewise, if you don't plan to use traditional fantasy creatures in your games (or can design one yourself for the occasional appearance in a modern setting), you're best off spending your $15.95 elsewhere. And, if you're just there for the art, buy the 2003 Fantasy Bestiary Calendar (which includes some stats from the book, and full-color artwork).

Still, the BESM Fantasy Bestiary does what it sets out to do: provide fantasy creature templates for PCs, NPCs, and monsters. If you're up for writing another chapter in the Record of Lodoss Wars, this book is for you.


Back to reviews index

Site copyright 2001-2014 Allan Sugarbaker. Trademarks/copyrights mentioned are owned by their respective owners.